Hits & Misses: ‘The Outsiders’ and ‘Monster at the End of This Book’

We’re back with another look at our writers’ favorite and least favorite book-to-screen adaptations. This time, Jen DePeppe, who reviewed “Beautiful Boy,” “Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret” and “Mean Girls” for Booked & Screened, shares a film that stayed true to a beloved book and another that left her disappointed.

Favorite: ‘The Outsiders’

One of my favorite book-to-film adaptations is “The Outsiders.” I saw the film in my early years and read the book as a teen. I even used both when I taught fifth and sixth grades.

The Outsiders
by S.E. Hinton
Grab yourself a copy of the book behind the adaptation.
Buy on Bookshop
As an affiliate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.

The 1967 novel, a gritty drama of class, violence, loyalty, loss and growth, was made into a film in 1983, directed by Francis Ford Coppola. Stacked with a cast of rising stars (be sure to check out Tom Cruise and his original teeth) and full of stunning sepia-tinted visuals, the film stays true to the book: teenager Ponyboy Curtis navigates economic struggles, fights and tragedy in 1960s Oklahoma.

Author S.E. Hinton, who finished writing the book at age 16, makes a cameo in the film as a nurse. Fox adapted “The Outsiders” as a television series in 1990 (look for a young David Arquette and Kim Walker from “Heathers”). “The Outsiders” is now a Tony Award-winning musical, reinforcing its status as a timeless classic that has stayed gold all these years.

Least favorite: ‘The Monster at the End of This Book’

The Monster at the End of This Book
by Jon Stone
Grab yourself a copy of the book behind the adaptation.
Buy on Bookshop
As an affiliate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.

My favorite book of all time is “The Monster at the End of This Book” by Jon Stone. This Sesame Street classic was first published in 1971. I ADORED this book and begged to hear it over and over. I’ve read it to my niece countless times.

In 2020, the 30-minute animated special, directed by Mark Taylor, premiered on HBO Max. It was titled “The Monster at the End of This Story.”

Meh. It’s animated. Grover is still scared, but he meets his friends along the way who encourage him to be brave.

And yeah, we could all use that.

While the theme remains, I was disappointed by the choice of animation over using the classic Muppet puppet.

Leave a Reply