‘Are You There, God?’: It’s your book and film review

Judy Blume’s “Are You There, God? It’s Me, Margaret” has been a staple in the diet of adolescents for decades. First published in 1970, Blume’s story of soon-to-be 12-year-old Margaret and her navigation through prepubescence also examines friendship, identity, body image and organized religion. These themes landed it on the American Library Association’s list of the most challenged books. It was banned in my school’s library in the early 1980s.

Are You There, God? It’s Me, Margaret

Director: Kelly Fremon Craig


Overall rating

★
★
★
★
★

5

Adaptation rating

★
★
★
★
★

5

In 2023, “Are You There, God? It’s Me, Margaret” was adapted for the screen, written and directed by Kelly Fremon Craig. Blume had rejected several adaptation offers for close to 50 years, apprehensive that Hollywood would spoil the story her readers kept so dear. 

I ADORED this book as a kid, reading and sharing it over and over. Margaret is anxious, curious and confused as she navigates the awkward world of adolescence. She wants to belong, be normal, have friends; at times she hates her friends. She wants to be kissed. She wants boobs, her period, to be older. She wants to know what all of these things feel like. And I remember really resonating with these themes at that age. I consider it one of my favorite books of all time. 

Rereading it as an adult, Margaret’s quiet honesty is still present. Angst doesn’t really expire. But it’s the religion theme I really connected with now. 

Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret.
by Judy Blume
Grab yourself a copy of the book behind the adaptation.
Buy on Bookshop
As an affiliate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.

Eleven-going-on-twelve Margaret Simon moves from New York City to suburban New Jersey right before starting the sixth grade. She keeps an ongoing inner dialogue with God, sharing her thoughts, fears and her daily goings on. 

Margaret meets Nancy and joins her club with Gretchen and Janie, where they discuss boys, bras, periods and other classmates. It’s at their first meeting that Margaret’s background becomes another central theme of the book AND another thing for her to worry about: Will she and her family join the Y or the Jewish Community Center because, as Nancy says, everybody belongs to one or the other. After this first club meeting, Margaret begins to ask God for help with growing a chest and guidance on where her religious affiliation should be. 

Margaret’s mom, Barbara, is Christian. Herb, her father, is Jewish. Barbara’s parents, whom Margaret has never met, would not accept Herb as her husband. Herb’s mother, Sylvia, did accept the relationship and continues to be an integral part of Margaret’s life: calling her every day, making her sweaters, taking her to Lincoln Center for concerts. Margaret later laments that she had lived in New York City for 11 and half years and no one asked her about religion, but now, all of a sudden, it was the big thing in her life.

It’s so big she decides to devote an assigned yearlong school project to religion. She visits Temple on Rosh Hashanah with Sylvia, much to Sylvia’s delight. She also goes to services with Janie and Nancy. During her visits, she keeps that dialogue with God, constantly looking for a feeling, a presence of some sort. Not exactly a sign, but the connection she feels when she talks to God on her own. She finally wishes she was born into a religion because choosing is just too difficult. 

All of this happens as Margaret battles body image woes, wanting to dance with Philip Leroy and a friend whose lies make it hard to be her friend. This kid’s got a lot on her plate.

Kelly Fremon Craig’s strong script and direction did not disappoint. I can fully understand why Judy Blume finally said, “Yup … this is the one.” 

Margaret, played by Abby Ryder Fortson, is anxious, curious and confused as she steers through early puberty in early 1970s New Jersey. She’s shy yet endearing and believable as Margaret Simon, with her bobby pins in her hair, her plaid dresses and loafers without socks. She has her chats with God, mostly in her room, sometimes kneeling at her bed. But the chats seem like a new thing while the book has Margaret explain it’s something she’s been doing for a while. The religion theme is brought up by her teacher, Mr. Benedict, played by Echo Kellum, who guides her to use religion as a topic for her yearlong research project. 

While Blume’s “Margaret” is all about Margaret and Margaret only, Fremon Craig’s “Margaret” also includes small subtle subplots about Barbara, played by Rachel McAdams, and Sylvia, played by Kathy Bates. Barbara is a former art teacher who also struggles with fitting in with the PTA mom crowd. She’s often overwhelmed and can’t get started, only coming alive when she paints. Sylvia, more meddlesome and overbearing here than in the book (yet still lovable), battles loneliness after Margaret moves to New Jersey. Margaret’s dad, played by Benny Safdie, is silly yet loving and stern, standing up to Sylvia on more than one occasion. In the book, Herb has a presence, but it’s muted.

Fremon Craig succeeds at keeping many of Blume’s details and they transfer wonderfully to the film. Sylvia’s hair color changes about once a month. Herb cuts his hand on the lawn mower. Laura Danker is a source of mockery and jealousy and Moose Freed is number one in Margaret’s Boy Book. Most notably, Margaret’s friend Nancy Wheeler, amazingly portrayed by Elle Graham, is quite possibly the biggest bitch in the world. She walks into Margaret’s house like she owns the place and, just like the book, Margaret hasn’t quite figured her out … yet.

Unlike in the book, Margaret is unaware of Barbara’s relationship with her parents. Movie Margaret asks why the family doesn’t see them and Barbara tearfully explains. As Margaret tenderly comforts her, she sees how religion can divide families. This is later cemented when Barbara’s parents decide to visit, a plot in both film and book. It solidifies when Sylvia and her friend Morris also visit, leading to an explosive argument over Margaret’s religious intentions. Not in the book, but makes for a great story arc.

When Margaret wraps up her yearlong project, she gives a letter to Mr. Benedict, explaining what she’s learned. Her takeaway: Religion causes people to fight and she’s not really sure God exists.

Both versions of Margaret end the same yet Fremon Craig’s has more closure. Without spoiling anything, both Margaret and Barbara become more independent, realize others are wrong and feel secure standing on their own two feet. In Blume’s “Margaret,” she is slowly seeing people for who they are and you can infer her confidence will build over time. 

While the book is a definite pre-teen staple, the film is for everyone. And keep an eye out for the Judy Blume cameo.

About the writer

Jen fulfilled a childhood dream and met Judy Blume at a book signing in 2015. They became good friends… in her head. 

One response to “‘Are You There, God?’: It’s your book and film review”

  1. I can’t imagine preteen years in the 1980’s without Judy Blume!

Leave a Reply