Review: Comparing ‘Beautiful Boy,’ ‘Tweak’ and the 2018 adaptation

“Beautiful Boy: A Father’s Journey Through His Son’s Addiction,” by David Sheff, was published in 2008 and expanded on Sheff’s New York Times Magazine article “My Addicted Son.” That same year, son Nic Sheff published his own memoir, “Tweak: Growing Up on Methamphetamines,” offering his perspective on addiction, recovery and family.

Beautiful Boy

Director: Felix Van Groeningen


Overall rating

★
★
★
★
★

3

Adaptation rating

★
★
★
★
★

3

The books were later adapted into the 2018 film “Beautiful Boy,” starring Steve Carell and Timothée Chalamet.

David Sheff’s book is heartbreaking and brutal. It is also incredibly descriptive. At times, almost distractingly so. The writing can feel overwritten, heavy with emotional language and cultural references. 

From the first pages, you can see that David reveres his son. He describes him with constant admiration—from his looks to his musical tastes to his ability to quote movies. Nic often feels less like a normal teenager and more like this glowing, tragic figure his father is endlessly in awe of.

There are also endless references to music, films and pop culture throughout the memoir. At times it adds texture, but at others it feels performative, as if the reader is constantly being reminded that the father and son are hip, trendy and ahead of their time (eyeroll).

I don’t doubt the pain the family experienced, and I wouldn’t wish addiction on anyone. But there’s an undercurrent of privilege running through the memoir that became frustrating for me as a reader.

The parenting dynamic especially stood out. David often comes across less like a disciplinarian and more like a devastated friend desperately trying to stay connected to his son. The memoir unintentionally raises questions about boundaries.

It’s never stated, but this reader could tell … Nic was never told “no.”

I remember when the book first came out, the father and son appeared on “Oprah,” and I am pretty sure she was annoyed too. 

Nic’s childhood is marked by instability early on. His parents divorced when he was very young. He split time between Northern California and Los Angeles, traveling between parents from an early age. By 11, he was experimenting with alcohol and marijuana. By 18, he was addicted to methamphetamine. What follows is the exhausting cycle that defines much of the memoir: lying, stealing, relapsing, rehab and recovery attempts.

And that cycle repeats for more than 300 pages.

After reading both books and watching the film adaptation, I found Nic’s memoir more emotionally revealing—you could feel the cry for help. It is far rougher stylistically. “Tweak” reads almost like an unfiltered diary—choppy, impulsive and chaotic. The writing is messy and repetitive.

David Sheff’s writing is technically stronger and more controlled. You can feel his anguish, his frustration and definitely the love for his son. He does blame himself and his past actions but not too much.

The film adaptation succeeds largely because of the performances. Chalamet convincingly captures not only addiction, but the angst, insecurity and loneliness. 

Carell brings warmth, fear and genuine desperation to David.

Together, the performances help bring both sides of the Sheffs’ story to life … sorta. 

While the acting is there, the story has plenty of gaps. The film uses many brief flashbacks to show Nic’s promising youth and David’s fondness for those times and confusion as to where and how it all went wrong. Yet the non-linear story felt choppy and rushed. It probably would have benefited from focusing more on Nic’s unconventional upbringing and mental health struggles. 

 About the author

Jen DePeppe likes biographies, fiction and medical journals. When her arthritis isn’t flaring, she runs and lifts weights. 

2 responses to “Review: Comparing ‘Beautiful Boy,’ ‘Tweak’ and the 2018 adaptation”

  1. I’m a fan of Carell but perhaps this is a skip! Thank you for the info

  2. This is one that I have skipped for a while because it always hit too close to home but with distance now it might a good read/watch.

Leave a Reply